Ouch, I don’t think I’ve ever gotten so emotional drawing a piece as this one, I hope other Clay fans can forgive me. This was for the @clayspacezine Infinite and Beyond, a free digital zine you can check here!
Wright’s inner monologue: this is so stupid, you all suck… (Random person passes by) I could take him (Not in a fight.)
Edgeworth’s inner monologue: HM, this trinket is so interesting… Logically (organizes simple things step by step). The world is fascinating.
Apollo’s inner monologue: What if I light something on fire. So tempted to break that window right now. Wish I was sitting in a throne and my boss was crawling at my feet.
Analyzing Klavier’s Behavior Because I Am Nothing If Not Predictable*
*But also I made this post at 2am and am determined to see it through
Alright so a few days ago I posted this reblog of a response to a post I made mentioning that Klavier’s behavior that is so commonly poked at as “Klavier, there was a murder” could very well be a coping mechanism. As you’ll know if you’ve read the essay I wrote on the parallels between Ryulock and Homumiko, I really like to analyze fictional characters. So I have decided to analyze Klavier Gavin’s behavior throughout his appearances because there’s implications in there that I think aren’t talked about enough.
(Also important to note because I feel like it’ll come up; this is all my interpretation of Klavier’s behavior based on a combination of personal experience and just how I read his behavior. I am not going to claim my analysis to be objectively correct.)
Part 1: A Brief-ish Summary of Klavier’s Canon Appearances
Klavier’s only canon appearances are in Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney and Turnabout Academy in Dual Destinies (which is a shame but that’s not my point). In the latter, he’s not acting as Prosecutor Gavin, he’s acting as Rock God Klavier. I still think, for the sake of context, it’s important to go over these appearances and how he acts during each one.
Turnabout Corner
Our first introduction to Klavier is in Turnabout Corner, the second episode of Apollo Justice. He’s introduced as a cool, suave prosecutor that likes to throw his weight around a little (as indicated by him overriding the police and allowing Trucy and Apollo to investigate People Park), and it’s easy to (correctly) assume pretty early on that he doesn’t really care about giving information to the defense like every other prosecutor in the series (something that will come up later). In Turnabout Corner, we also learn about Klavier’s status as a rockstar, and how he usually acts during court proceedings. Apollo’s first impression, which carries over into Turnabout Serenade and is still part of how he sees Klavier into Dual Destinies, is that Klavier tends to not take things very seriously.
Turnabout Serenade
Turnabout Serenade is… interesting. We see a side of Klavier that he seems to want to keep under wraps at first — he’s a perfectionist when it comes to his music, and his focus is on Daryan’s missed cue, not the fact that a murder happened at his concert; notably, he’s focused on Daryan’s fuck-up, when he’s not the only one who messed up during the concert. He comes off as irritable during investigation segments, seeming to put on a mask of his usual confident and carefree attitude when Apollo and Trucy show up.
This is also the first time Klavier starts to get honestly pretty mean when even the implication that something he didn’t want to be true is true is suggested. The second Apollo implies LeTouse was murdered during the second set (which is when he first presents the igniter) Klavier gets mean (“Herr Forehead, don’t destroy what little respect I have for you!” which implies he never had much respect for him in the first place, which I’d argue is not the case but I’ll get into that later). We get into Daryan’s testimony once it’s made clear that Daryan’s a suspect, and at that point he’s less mean to Apollo and tearing into Daryan instead. Turnabout Serenade alone shows that Klavier’s views of people can and will change on a dime.
Turnabout Succession (2019 section)
I’m gonna get it out of the way now, Klavier is a brat during the 2019 section of Turnabout Succession. This is relevant; he seems to have grown out of this by Turnabout Corner, but he’s still prone to being a dick. Klavier’s also much more egotistical during the 2019 section of Turnabout Succession; most notably, he brags about the success of The Gavinners multiple times during the trial (which Phoenix describes as an “utter lack of humility”). As a 24/25-year-old, he’s not normally an egocentric asshole; this trait only really shows itself during times where he’d be stressed. Again, we’ll get to that.
Turnabout Succession (responses to Kristoph’s involvement)
The first reaction to Kristoph’s involvement is when Vera mentions the commemorative stamp with Troupe Gramarye on it, and he gets intense about asking Vera about what the first forgery she made was. He actually scares Vera and concerns the judge:
And this is where he first breaks down. Trucy gets concerned, Apollo has to tell him to calm the fuck down because he’s badgering the witness (at which point Klavier calls Phoenix Apollo’s “soiled, sullied mentor”), and then Vera collapses from atroquinine poisoning and the trial ends. I cannot imagine what the next span of time before the trial continued was like for Klavier.
Once Kristoph actually takes the stand, Klavier’s quite quiet for a while, aside from defending Kristoph when you press certain statements (and even then, Kristoph will not hesitate to talk over Klavier). Apollo even mentions that Klavier’s acting different, and decides it’s because Kristoph’s in the courtroom. Klavier gets so upset that he can’t even function properly, which Kristoph blames on Apollo (“My, my. You’ve upset my poor brother to the point of uselessness.”). Klavier does eventually snap out of it and accuses Kristoph of bluffing, and the rest of the trial he works with Apollo to convince the jurists that Kristoph is behind Drew and Vera’s poisoning, not Vera (although he does tell Apollo he’s leaving the case if he can’t prove Kristoph is behind forging the evidence in the Zak Gramarye case).
Klavier’s behavior in the 2026 sections of Turnabout Succession very much remind me of 17-year-old Klavier, and his breakdown sprite does not help this (which I’ve also done an analysis on. Parts of that analysis will be relevant later). Again, this will come up later.
Turnabout Academy
I personally think Klavier’s behavior in Turnabout Academy is also similar to his behavior when he was 17, although in the complete opposite direction from Turnabout Succession. Looking at Klavier’s behavior in Turnabout Succession’s 2019 section vs his behavior during Turnabout Academy, I am immediately struck by similarities. Notably, Klavier exhibits some degree of inflated self-confidence (he calls his own voice “godlike” if you present the tape recorder to him, tells Apollo and Athena to find the Gavinners banner, leading Athena to wonder if he just wants his banner back, claims the burnt fragments of the Gavinners banner is a “challenge directed at [Klavier] and Gavinners fans everywhere”), which leads him to put down Apollo specifically (telling Apollo that the role of a fledgling lawyer is one he was “born to play,” calling Apollo a wet blanket, “That feigned swagger does not suit you in the least,” probably jokingly accusing Apollo of destroying the statues of Klavier and Phoenix).
It’s all behavior that feels like it should come from 17-year-old Klavier, not 25-year-old Klavier, at least not under most circumstances.
Part 2: A Slightly More In-Depth Analysis of Klavier’s Behavior
Klavier’s behavior, notably, changes depending on the circumstances he’s in. I think it’s important to figure out what the baseline for adult Klavier’s behavior is before we go any further however.
I, personally, think the baseline for Klavier’s behavior is most clear in Turnabout Corner. He doesn’t have any personal involvement in the case beyond Apollo getting Kristoph thrown in prison, and he’s pretty chill the entire case. It feels like, at the very least, he’s adhering to his rock god persona (and I don’t think it’s a stretch to assume that’s at least partially what he’s like when he’s not masking anything). Turnabout Corner serving as the baseline for Klavier’s behavior also makes sense from a writing standpoint. So, I’m going to use Turnabout Corner as a baseline for Klavier’s behavior. Now that we have that out of the way, let’s analyze Klavier’s behavior.
Part 2.1: Turnabout Serenade
So, first of all, let’s look at the transition from Turnabout Corner to Turnabout Serenade. Klavier’s having fun, he’s at a concert and performing with someone he looks up to and admires. Then, tragedy strikes. A murder happens during the third set. The pianist for the second set is arrested. Daryan missed a cue he shouldn’t have missed. This is the first time Klavier is aggressive. It’s the first time we see perfectionist Klavier. The second Apollo and Trucy show up, he starts acting like he did during Turnabout Corner. To be completely clear, I do think he was genuinely happy to see them. I don’t think his behavioral change when Apollo and Trucy show up is entirely a front. At worst, he’s pretending everything’s fine by acting like he normally would. Two explanations I can think of for this:
Maybe he just doesn’t want Trucy and Apollo to see him like that.
Maybe he doesn’t actually care how Trucy and Apollo see him, and he pretends everything’s fine by instinct.
Additionally, this is the first time we truly see the extent of how egocentric Klavier can get. He opts to completely ignore the fact that a murder happened at his concert and instead focuses on Daryan’s missed cue. That’s what we see, at least.
By the end of the case we find out that missed cue was crucial evidence. That missed cue had implications for the entire incident. It’s also implied in Turnabout Corner that Klavier is always multiple steps ahead, and in Turnabout Academy he suggests that the missing Gavinners banner is relevant to the case, and it ends up being crucial to the case. Exactly like Daryan’s missed cue.
I don’t think Klavier was just being an egocentric asshole here. I think he knew that the missed cue was somehow relevant, especially if he noticed Lamiroir and Machi’s mistakes during the second set. If he did notice the mistakes Lamiroir and Machi made, then noticed Daryan’s missed cue, I don’t doubt he’d think they were somehow related. The one thing saving him was that the entire case, both the defense’s side and the prosecution’s side, hinged on the murder taking place during the third set, so he gets fucking mean when it’s implied the murder might’ve happened during the second set, because there goes any plausible denial. Once Apollo suggests the murder happened during the second set, Daryan’s alibi goes out the window, and he becomes their prime suspect. Basically, Klavier’s aggression in Turnabout Serenade, and potentially how set on figuring out Daryan’s missed cue he was, was very likely him getting defensive.
Part 2.2: Turnabout Succession
Not gonna talk about the 2019 section of Turnabout Succession much here. Klavier’s behavior in Turnabout Succession is very much like his behavior in Turnabout Corner. That is, until Kristoph is made a suspect in Drew Misham’s murder.
Klavier’s pretty much the same as he was in Turnabout Corner for most of the first trial of Turnabout Succession. He’s enjoying himself (a fact Apollo and Trucy mention), he’s having fun teasing Spark Brushel a bit.
And then Vera brings up the commemorative stamp with Troupe Gramarye on it. As I mentioned above, he gets so intense about finding out what Vera’s first forgery was that he scares Vera, concerns the judge, concerns Trucy, and has Apollo telling him to calm the fuck down because he’s badgering the witness. Even taking 17-year-old Klavier into account, that’s incredibly out of character for him. 17-year-old Klav was a bit mean to witnesses, sure, but he never badgered them. This exact moment is where, upon replaying AJ:AA, I was like “holy shit, you can pinpoint exactly where and when Klavier realizes Kristoph’s involved in this.”
During the next trial day, he’s out of character on the complete opposite end of the spectrum, by which I mean he’s too quiet. Klavier’s usually talkative and flamboyant. He likes to test Apollo and Apollo’s theories. He likes getting under Apollo’s skin. But the second Kristoph’s on the witness stand we don’t get any of that. He’s just quiet and he lets Kristoph talk over him. Kristoph’s presence is enough to make him uncharacteristically quiet (which makes me wonder what the fuck their history is, especially with Klavier’s “Spinning out of whose control? Mine? …Or yours?” line after Kristoph says he’s spinning out of control and the fact that what triggers Kristoph saying that in the first place is Klavier saying “Let’s clean out the family closet” and Kristoph claims Klavier’s going to say something he’ll regret, but that’s a different post for a different time). Klavier eventually gets so desperate for proof that Kristoph killed Drew and tried to kill Vera that he literally begs Apollo to prove it. Once Klavier has seen evidence that would indicate that Kristoph is guilty of Drew’s murder, he’s mostly back to his normal self.
Part 2.3: Turnabout Academy
Turnabout Academy is interesting because Klavier’s behavior still feels off but you aren’t playing as Apollo; you’re playing as Athena, who doesn’t know what Klavier is usually like. Klavier’s a lot nicer to Athena than he is to Apollo (he is still a bit mean to Athena at points, just to be clear). I personally think it’s because Klavier knows Apollo but doesn’t know Athena well, but that’s just an assumption, I don’t think there’s really evidence to support it.
Anyway, Klavier’s behavior during Turnabout Academy feels pretty similar to when he was 17 in my opinion. He is brutal with Apollo. Klavier:
Tells Apollo that the role of a fledgling defense attorney is one he “was born to play”
Calls Apollo a wet blanket
Calls Apollo a stick in the mud
Accuses Apollo of destroying the statues of Klavier and Phoenix TWICE (probably jokingly but that’s still mean, Klavier. This is also, notably, reflective of Klavier accusing Apollo of setting his guitar on fire in Turnabout Serenade)
17-year-old Klavier, while he doesn’t target anyone specifically, is a fucking brat. He’s irritating and he likes harassing people (like how 17-year-old Klavier was ever allowed in a court of law is beyond me. Granted this is the same court system that let an 18-year-old with a whip prosecute cases but I digress). In some of 17-year-old Klav’s dialogue, we also get a taste of just how egocentric he could get at 17. Some of 17-year-old Klavier’s lines in the 2019 section of Turnabout Succession that had me like “wow, never has a more irritating 17-year-old existed”:
“Herr Detective, this is my stage. Can the antics.”
“And I haven’t proven anything yet, beyond my good looks, and startling record sales.”
“…Would you hold me accountable for a mistake made in my youth?” “That was just this morning!” “…I am still young.”
“I would hope the defense refrains from its customarily broad, sweeping accusations.”
“…Truly, there’s no substitute for experience. Nothing blinds one to the truth so effectively.”
I can 100% see some of those lines also coming from Turnabout Academy Klavier. That then begs the question; if Klavier had evolved past acting like this by the age of 24, why is he back to acting like that by the age of 25?
Simple; it’s very likely the same reason his behavior was the way it was in Turnabout Serenade. Constance Courte had personal significance to Klavier and quite literally shaped how Klavier prosecutes cases. Klavier says this himself; “She may have taught the judge course, but she had a huge impact on me. She was fond of saying, ‘The end is only justified through proper means.’ She wouldn’t tolerate dishonesty and always revered what was right beyond all else.” From the beginning of the case, it’s had more personal significance than any of the cases Klavier prosecuted (while other cases did have personal significance to him, it was only ever clear near the end of the trial).
The thing about Turnabout Academy is that, in terms of Klavier’s role in the story, it is incredibly similar to Turnabout Serenade. Here’s a list of similarities just to show what I mean:
Both cases involve Klavier having Apollo and the individual he’s investigating with figure out something that doesn’t seem to be significant to the case but is actually crucial evidence (Daryan’s missed cue in Turnabout Serenade and the Gavinners banner in Turnabout Academy)
Both have personal significance to Klavier in some way (Daryan was the culprit of Turnabout Serenade and his mentor is the victim of Turnabout Academy)
You would not be blamed for saying “Klavier there was a MURDER” every time he shows up in both cases
Klavier’s roles in Turnabout Serenade and Turnabout Academy are similar enough to me that it caught my attention almost immediately (in fact, I tagged the screenshot I posted of Klavier telling Apollo and Athena to look for the Gavinners banner as “turnabout serenade ass behavior”). That also means that his behavior is similar in both cases; the primary difference, in my opinion at least, is that Klavier’s more intense and mean in Turnabout Academy (which was obvious to be quite quickly).
Part 2.4: Klavier’s Shifting View of Kristoph
(This isn’t important I just wanted to bring it up)
It’s made pretty clear in Turnabout Succession’s 2019 section that Klavier has a positive view of Kristoph. Klavier takes Kristoph at his word that Phoenix is going to present forged evidence and keeps him anonymous when he mentions that he gave him the tip that Phoenix would present forged evidence. He was excited to go against him in court (which just makes the fact that Kristoph forged evidence to beat him a lot more sad), something he even acknowledges when it’s made clear that Kristoph forged the diary page that got Phoenix disbarred (“…Kristoph! We were supposed to face each other in that trial! A fair fight, brother to brother! I deserved that much! You let me borrow the victim’s belongings… …You showed me all your research on the case!”).
We can literally watch this crumble during Turnabout Succession. He knows Kristoph is a good defense attorney; when Apollo first meets Klavier in court, Klavier says that he’s prosecuting the case because he wanted to see the true strength of “the little boy who bested” Kristoph, which at the very least implies he respects Kristoph’s skills as a defense attorney. That’s completely crumbled by the end of Turnabout Succession, with Klavier literally telling Kristoph “You’re not needed anymore.” It’s honestly really sad to watch too. It makes you wonder what was going through his head during that span of time during Vera’s trial where Klavier’s just not as talkative as he usually is and Kristoph’s on the witness stand.
(To be clear, I think Klavier knew Kristoph was a piece of shit before Turnabout Succession. I don’t think Kristoph’s emotional abuse of Klavier started during Turnabout Succession, and I very much think Klavier knew that Kristoph was a piece of shit because of it. However, I don’t really think he would’ve expected anything that came out during Turnabout Succession, which is why he reacts how he does. I also think it would be safe to assume that either Kristoph only started emotionally abusing Klavier after Zak’s trial or Klavier realized that’s what he was doing after Zak’s trial, due to Klavier’s attitude toward Kristoph holding the implication that if Kristoph was actively being abusive at that point in time, Klavier didn’t realize it)
Part 3: What We Can Conclude About Klavier Based On This Information
I’ve mentioned it before (in fact it’s in the Klavier breakdown animation analysis I linked earlier in the post), but Klavier’s behavior comes off as him not having been able to properly grow up, whether because he became a celebrity when he was 17 or for some other reason. It’s like he regresses back to 17 during traumatic situations, or possibly has some sort of relapse if we assume he got mental health treatment between the 2019 section of Turnabout Succession and the start of Turnabout Corner, and his behavior supports that, which is fucking heartbreaking. It’s like he’s putting on a mask of maturity because he was forced to. By who? Could be anyone. He could’ve felt obligated to do it by his status as an international celebrity. He could’ve been pressured into it by the Gavinners’ record label (assuming they weren’t indie). Kristoph could’ve pressured him into it because Klavier had eyes on his every action on a global scale. He could’ve experienced some kind of psychological trauma that caused it. There are so many potential explanations here and they’re all fucking heartbreaking.
Part 4: Conclusion
So. 3.3k words later. This is longer than my Ryulock/Homumiko essay. Anyway, conclusion: I don’t think Klavier’s ever been flanderized. I think people are misreading his primary trauma response (that being, some form of regression or relapse). He’s not even the only person this happens to in the series (*stares at Athena*), it’s just not obvious with Klavier if you don’t consider ALL his behavior together, including his behavior when he’s 17 because that’s really what explains his behavior in my opinion. Klavier’s behavior isn’t easily explainable in a nearly 3.5k word essay without knowing how he was at 17.
And yes, you could argue that this is all coincidence. You could argue that none of this was intentional, especially when you consider how Ace Attorney is written. Someone who goes into Dual Destinies without playing Apollo Justice first won’t get the additional context required to recognize the full extent of Klavier’s behavior.
I would beg to differ however. Some of Phoenix’s bitchiness from Apollo Justice is still present in Dual Destinies and Spirit of Justice, and I very much think that was intentional. Apollo’s behavior in 5-4 and 5-5 are very much indicative of him having trust issues as a result of everything that happened with Kristoph and that’s a hill I’ll die on. Simon still acts the same as he did in prison, likely as a result of either trauma, habit, or both.
If you think Ace Attorney doesn’t reference past games in characters’ behavior, you’re underestimating Ace Attorney’s writing. I absolutely think Klavier’s behavior in Turnabout Academy and his behavior in Turnabout Serenade are meant to be reflective of each other. I’d be genuinely surprised if that’s not an intentional parallel and if it doesn’t indicate something about Klavier’s response to traumatic events. Even worse, I am quite sure that Kristoph has put him down over this. Hell, you could argue that his comment about Klavier being stressed to the point of uselessness is him putting Klavier down for how he copes with trauma. It explains why he was so quiet while Kristoph was on the witness stand, actually.
I also don’t think Klavier’s as egocentric and quite as much of a perfectionist as he lets on. I think it’s part of what I referred to earlier as Klavier relapsing. I very much think he might’ve been like that at 17, but much like his other behavior at 17 it feels like he grew out of it, and he has a tendency to fall back into it during traumatic situations, whether it’s as a defense mechanism or just how his brain responds to trauma.
Essentially this causes traumatic situations for Klavier to turn into him bottling everything up, which comes across to other people (including anyone who decides to play Apollo Justice and Dual Destinies) as irritability. This happens to me too; I’m prone to emotional overreaction but I’ve gotten to a point where I tend to bottle it up instead of doing literally anything else.
Capcom, please for the love of the Holy Mother give Klavier therapy.
i wholeheartedly believe clay terran was the funniest (and most frustrating) motherfucker to ever grace planet earth
- would always jailbreak new phones immediately & constantly had his location set to antarctica. this made it impossible to locate him
- sometimes screamed after he popped his neck and then pretended nothing happened (in public)
- found a bottle of ketchup in his grandma’s pantry that expired in 1999. proceeded to steal it and kept it at home in his shower to confuse any guests. he only had like 1 friend & apollo can’t really do anything but wonder about it now (“he was probably fucking with me, but it slowly started getting more empty….”)
— btw, when apollo went to clean out his apartment after everything happened, the bottle was gone. yuri cosmos later found it in clay’s HAT-2 belongings. he was 100% going to target starbuck with this in space.
- had a phase where he would only use microsoft bing & said “binging it” instead of “googling it”
- he had a bit of an irrational stapler fear because he got himself once, so until he got over it he’d MAKE APOLLO STAPLE THINGS FOR HIM. this included his GYAXA application.
— he got over it one day, but he kind of started punching staplers to get the job done. clay was ballsy and would jump fences & stage sabotages but he would get nervous around staplers. (“IT’S TOO CLOSE!” grown ass man)
- was very conventionally attractive & overall kind. so “how are you still single?” was a common question at bars until clay started ranting (unprompted) about how much he hated the voice they use at crosswalks or some shit (“oh. that’s why.”)
- never really cared about winning in multiplayer games or anything. he just really really wanted to make sure a person of his choosing lost. cosmos picked the right guy for the job — sabotage was in his blood since day 1 when he was steering himself and apollo off the rails in that mario party minecart race
— btw he mained donkey kong in mario party. if you stole donkey kong from him you would be losing that game hell or high waters. he is stealing ALL YOUR STARS
- did his taxes on the last possible day (that, or apollo would do them for him because as much as he loved the guy, he really didn’t have high faith he’d get around to it. he…………. also probably did wright’s taxes while he was in the beanix phase. ….and athena’s because she didn’t know how. oh, someone please save apollo.)
I think edgeworth and apollo would get each other so well, it OVER for wright
Like Edgeworth would probably want to thank the guy who helped Wright solve the cases from aa4 and took care of him when Wright didnt allow him to get into his life because of some sense of pride. I feel Apollo helps Wright lower a lot of defenses he automatically put up with edgeworth. And IMO Apollo would just be a nerd and fanboy of edgeworth too lmaoo.
Do you think everything that came out about Kristoph was traumatizing to Apollo? Do you think he’s ever thought back to his apprenticeship under Kristoph and thought “would I have been next if he hadn’t been arrested?” Do you think he’s had mental breakdowns and panic attacks over it?
I think it’d be really funny if Apollo, despite getting up at 5am for voice exercises, is not a morning person and actually tends to be incredibly irritable if he wakes up earlier than like 7 or 8, and even then he continues to be pretty irritable until he’s eaten something. I 100% think that on weekends he sleeps in until like 11 or noon unless something wakes him up
Something I think is interesting about Apollo is that he very much considers Khura'in his home (he explicitly states this during the first investigation section in Turnabout Revolution; specifically, he mentions waiting for Dhurke to go back to the states and take him back home) but he also makes mention of (probably) purposely trying to forget about Khura'in. It’s so interesting to me because he very much seems to consider Dhurke and Nahyuta family from the first time mention is made that Apollo grew up in Khura'in, and he seems to have kept his knowledge of the Khura'inese language sharp (as he reads Dhurke’s law agency sign with no issues, despite not being in Khura'in for over a decade).
Makes me wonder if he eventually was in America for so long that he just gave up on ever going back and tried to forget Khura'in existed so he wouldn’t be in a perpetual state of homesickness.
It also makes me wonder if, had Spirit of Justice been planned out at the time Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney was developed, Apollo would inject Khura'inese phrases into his dialogue. He’s attached enough to Khura'in that even a decade later he seems to consider Khura'in home, I’d be surprised if he doesn’t add Khura'inese phrases to his speech.
